Look, I need to be honest with you. When I first saw the headlines about Stranger Things Season 5 getting slammed by critics, my heart sank a little. After years of watching Mike, Eleven, and the gang fight monsters and navigate the absolute chaos of growing up, the idea that their final chapter was being labeled the "worst" felt... wrong somehow.
The Weight of Expectations
Here's the thing about Stranger Things: it stopped being just a show somewhere around 2017. It became this cultural touchstone that reminded us what it felt like to ride bikes until streetlights came on, to believe in the impossible, and to know that friendship could literally save the world. So yeah, when the final season dropped, we weren't just watching a TV show end we were saying goodbye to something that mattered.
And that's exactly why the Rotten Tomatoes score stung so much.
Let's Talk About Those Early Seasons
Remember Season 1? God, that was special. It came out of nowhere and just grabbed us. The Duffer Brothers created something that felt simultaneously nostalgic and completely new. Critics ate it up, and honestly, they were right to.
Seasons 2 and 3 had their bumps sure, the show got bigger, louder, maybe stretched itself a bit thin at times. But we loved it anyway because we loved these characters. We'd invested in them. Season 4 went darker and longer, splitting itself into two volumes like it was the next Marvel event, and you know what? Most of us were still on board.
So What Happened with Season 5?
The critical consensus suggests Season 5 is the weakest link. Not terrible, mind you, just... less. And I get where some of that comes from, even if it frustrates me.
The Fatigue Factor
After eight years, some critics felt like they'd seen this dance before. Another threat to Hawkins, another race against time, another tearful reunion. When you've been covering the show professionally, maybe that formula starts to show its seams. For those of us who grew up alongside these kids though? That familiarity feels comforting, not repetitive.
Okay, I'll admit it some of these episodes are long. Like, cancel-your-evening long. The Duffers clearly wanted to give us a cinematic experience, and they delivered on that front. But there were moments where I found myself checking how much time was left, wondering if we really needed that particular subplot or extended sequence.
Character Goodbyes That Didn't Land
With this many characters to service, somebody was going to get shortchanged. Some arcs felt rushed while others overstayed their welcome. It's an impossible balancing act, but that doesn't make it less disappointing when your favorite character doesn't get the ending they deserve.
The Critics vs. Fans Thing
Here's where it gets interesting. While critics were lukewarm, fans? Fans were feeling this season. The audience scores tell a different story—one of emotional satisfaction, of catharsis, of finally getting to see these characters we've loved for nearly a decade find some kind of peace.
Why the divide? Because we're watching different shows.
Critics are analyzing structure, pacing, originality. They're asking whether the story justifies its runtime and if the mythology pays off in satisfying ways. Fair questions, honestly.
But fans? We're watching our friends. We're remembering where we were when we first binged Season 1. We're thinking about how these characters helped us through middle school, high school, maybe even college. When Eleven has a big moment, we're not critiquing the dialogue we're feeling seven years of growth and struggle crystallize in that instant.
What Season 5 Got Right
Despite the criticism, there's so much to love here. The performances are phenomenal you can feel the years of chemistry between these actors. The production value is insane; the Upside Down has never looked more terrifyingly beautiful. And those emotional beats? When they land, they land.
The season commits to being dark and final in a way that feels earned. These aren't kids anymore. The stakes aren't just about saving the town they're about confronting what all this trauma has done to them. That's heavy stuff, and not every critic appreciated the tonal shift, but it felt honest to me.
The Final Season Curse
Let's be real: final seasons almost never satisfy everyone. Game of Thrones, Lost, Dexter (both times), even The Sopranos endings are impossible. Everyone has their own version of how the story should conclude, and no single ending can honor all those imagined finales.
Stranger Things Season 5 was doomed to disappoint someone. The fact that it disappoints critics more than fans probably says something about what the show values most: emotional truth over narrative perfection.
Does the Score Matter?
In ten years, will we remember that Season 5 had a 68% on Rotten Tomatoes? Probably not. We'll remember how we felt watching it. We'll remember the moments that made us cry or cheer or hide behind our hands.
Scores are snapshots of critical consensus at a specific moment. They don't account for how stories grow on us, how our perspectives shift, or how nostalgia transforms our relationship with art. Some of the most beloved shows and movies of all time were critically panned on release.
What I'll Remember
I'll remember that Stranger Things gave us eight years of genuine magic. I'll remember that it made an entire generation fall in love with Kate Bush and care about Dungeons & Dragons. I'll remember that it showed us that stories about friendship and courage and growing up never get old even when the formula does.
Is Season 5 perfect? No. Is it the worst thing ever made? Also no. It's a messy, ambitious, deeply emotional conclusion to a story that meant something to millions of people. The Rotten Tomatoes score is just one data point in a much bigger, more complicated picture.
The Bottom Line
The "worst Rotten Tomatoes score in the franchise" sounds damning in a headline. But zoom out and you see a show that took risks, stuck the landing for most fans, and concluded with its heart intact. That's worth more than any score.
The Upside Down might be closed for good, but the impact of Stranger Things will linger. And honestly? That's the only review that matters.
No comments:
Post a Comment